I Was Just Catfished by an AI SDR: Why Human Sales Skills Are More Valuable Than Ever

For weeks, I believed I was speaking with the founder of a company that positions itself as “The Smartest LinkedIn Outbound Engine.”

I wasn’t.

What I experienced was a fully autonomous AI SDR—an artificial intelligence-powered sales agent that scraped my data, mimicked a human tone, nurtured me, and guided me toward booking a Zoom call.

Then Came the Twist

When I joined the call, here’s what actually happened:

  • The founder I thought I had been speaking with wasn’t there.
  • I was greeted by a sales rep I had never interacted with.
  • That rep had to pull up the AI logs just to catch up on our conversation.

Yes, he had deployed the AI SDR.
No, he wasn’t reviewing or approving messages in real time.

Which means: no human knew I existed until I entered the funnel.

It was technically impressive—and also a textbook bait and switch.

I chose to stay on the call. If the product worked on me, I wanted to understand why.


What Every Sales Professional Needs to Hear

This experience wasn’t just unusual—it was a glimpse into the new reality of AI-powered outreach.

If you are human and in sales, stay in sales.

AI won’t replace the human in the sales funnel.

  • It may reduce outbound workload
  • It may accelerate the pipeline
  • But a human is still needed to close the deal

If you’re in sales, now is the time to evolve:

  • Move up the value chain
  • Strengthen your relationship-building skills
  • Develop emotional intelligence—not just CRM fluency

The Gap I Experienced Is a Massive Opportunity

The human sales interaction I had during the call left a lot on the table.

There is real, unmet demand for advanced relationship-based selling and human-centered rep training. This is a goldmine for professionals who excel in:

  • Building trust
  • Navigating emotional nuance
  • Influencing decision-makers at key moments

Welcome to the Agentic Transformation

We’ve entered what I call the Agentic Transformation—a shift where autonomous agents manage more of the front-end process, and human interaction becomes the most valuable differentiator.

This moment signals something even bigger:

Communication skills will replace engineers.

Not because engineers aren’t essential—but because in a world of autonomous agents, humans who can communicate will close the deal.

I call this era: The Rise of the Liberal Arts Degrees—where empathy, storytelling, persuasion, and critical thinking are once again the most valuable tools in the room.


Final Thoughts

This wasn’t just an AI-driven sales sequence—it was a sign of what’s coming.

AI may handle the outreach.
But humans will still own the outcome.

If you’re a founder, marketer, sales leader, or communicator—now is the time to rethink how your teams balance automation with authentic, human connection.

The tools are evolving. Are your people?


Want more insight #prohuman AI, communication strategy, and the future of human connection in a post AI-LLM world?
Join my newsletter or connect with me on LinkedIn.